UA-45667900-1
Showing posts with label Carnosine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Carnosine. Show all posts

Tuesday 4 November 2014

Why not Cocoa Flavanols for Autism?







  
Judging by my blog statistics, lots of people are interested in broccoli (Sulforaphane) to treat autism.  Thanks to the patents held by Johns Hopkins, you can expect to hear much more about Sulforaphane in the coming years.

Meanwhile, Columbia University and Mars, the chocolate people, have released a study showing that “flavanoids” in cocoa can do wonders for memory loss in older people.  In effect, they can restore memory in 60 years olds to where it was 20 or 30 years earlier.

If you take a step back and look at what is known by science about oxidative stress and antioxidants, all will become much clearer.


Oxidative Stress Pioneers

In an earlier post we met Paul Talalay, a German-American, who worked at Johns Hopkins.  He specializes in foods that protect you from cancer.  He is Mr Broccoli. 

It turns out that perhaps the real pioneer in this field is a 100% German, called Helmut Sies, who also studies foods that act as antioxidants and nutrients that provide protection from cancer.  We have his very detailed diagram below, that explains the relationship between many of the factors involved in oxidative stress.  I wish I had found it earlier.  I added the six outer boxes.

If you want to read clever studies about this subject, just include Helmut Sies in your search; for example “selenium Helmut Sies”.


Redox Pioneer: Professor Helmut Sies













On this graphic you will see GSH (Glutathione).  When you take NAC (N-acetylcysteine) you directly raise the level of GSH.  When eat broccoli you activate Nrf2, which is a Redox switch, just under the traffic light in the graphic.

When you eat certain flavonoids, like Cocoa, or carotenoids like lycopene (found in tomatoes), you again promote the anti-oxidative free radical scavenger effect.  Look in the blue boxes under diet.

Not on the diagram, we also have flavonolignans which are natural phenols composed of a part flavonoid and a part lignan. As pointed out in a comment in the last post by Seth Bittker, one interesting  flavonolignan is Silibinin, which has anti-oxidant and chemoprotective effects

Note the presence of (Coenzyme) Q10 in the yellow box.  This is part of the mitochondrial cocktail suggested by Dr Kelley from Johns Hopkins for regressive autism.  Q10 is depleted by statins.

Glutathione peroxidases, in the yellow box, are also very interesting.  These are selenium-containing enzymes.  GPx (x goes from 1 to 8)  catalyze the reduction of H2O2 and organic hydroperoxides to harmless products. This function helps to maintain membrane integrity and to reduce further oxidative damage to molecules such as lipids and lipoproteins with the associated increased risk of conditions such as atherosclerosis.  It appears GP1 may be defective in autism and this is contributes to increased oxidative stress.  This area has been well studied due to its impact on heart disease.  You appear to be able to counter the lack of GPx with yeast-bound selenium, other forms of selenium do not work, due to a lack of bioavailability. A post will appear just on Selenium.

There are several other potent (exogenous) antioxidants that we have come across:-

  • Alpha lipoic acid also known as ALA or Tioctic acid (found  in Dr Kelley’s cocktail)
  •   L-Carnosine (studied by Dr Chez )
  •  Vitamin C (suggested by many, including Dr Kelley)


Another day, another anti-oxidant

In human health, two well used anti-oxidant drugs are Alpha lipoic Acid (ALA,  also known as Tioctic acid) and N-acetyl cysteine (NAC).  They share many similar effects.

  •       Potent antioxidant
  •       Increase insulin sensitivity
  •       Improve memory in those with mild cognitive          impairment
  •       May lower blood pressure
  •       Improve behavior in autism

NAC is widely used to treat Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and ALA is used to treat diabetic neuropathy. Perhaps they could be interchanged

·        NAC has a chemoprotective effect
·        ALA has been shown to induce cell cycle arrest in  human breast cancers      cells

Back to Cocoa Flavanols and Mars

This flurry of activity was driven by a well publicized study done at Columbia University Medical Center (CUMC), using a high cocoa flavanol concentration drink provided by Mars.


   
In the CUMC study, 37 healthy volunteers, ages 50 to 69, were randomized to receive either a high-flavanol diet (900 mg of flavanols a day) or a low-flavanol diet (10 mg of flavanols a day) for three months. Brain imaging and memory tests were administered to each participant before and after the study. The brain imaging measured blood volume in the dentate gyrus, a measure of metabolism, and the memory test involved a 20-minute pattern-recognition exercise designed to evaluate a type of memory controlled by the dentate gyrus.
The high-flavanol group also performed significantly better on the memory test. “If a participant had the memory of a typical 60-year-old at the beginning of the study, after three months that person on average had the memory of a typical 30- or 40-year-old,” said Dr. Small. He cautioned, however, that the findings need to be replicated in a larger study—which he and his team plan to do.


This is very impressive.  But how do the other anti-oxidants compare?

Well, without funding from Mars, researchers only managed the money to test ALA and NAC on mice; but as you might expect, the result was similar.


Chronic administration of either LA or NAC improved cognition of 12-month-old SAMP8 mice in both the T-maze footshock avoidance paradigm and the lever press appetitive task without inducing non-specific effects on motor activity, motivation to avoid shock, or body weight. These effects probably occurred directly within the brain, as NAC crossed the blood-brain barrier and accumulated in the brain. Furthermore, treatment of 12-month-old SAMP8 mice with LA reversed all three indexes of oxidative stress. These results support the hypothesis that oxidative stress can lead to cognitive dysfunction and provide evidence for a therapeutic role for antioxidants.



Cocoa Flavanols are good for your heart

This is also good news, but it does seem that antioxidants are generally very good for your heart.

First cocoa.

In this study blood pressure, glucose, insulin and cholesterol were all markedly affected for the better by the cocoa as was cognitive function.

This is great;  but it is what Helmut Sies has been telling the world for many years.


Abstract—Flavanol consumption is favorably associated with cognitive function. We tested the hypothesis that dietary flavanols might improve cognitive function in subjects with mild cognitive impairment. We conducted a double-blind, parallel arm study in 90 elderly individuals with mild cognitive impairment randomized to consume once daily for 8 weeks a drink containing _990 mg (high flavanols), _520 mg (intermediate flavanols), or _45 mg (low flavanols) of cocoa flavanols per day. Cognitive function was assessed by Mini Mental State Examination, Trail Making Test A and B, and verbal fluency test. At the end of the follow-up period, Mini Mental State Examination was similar in the 3 treatment groups (P_0.13). The time required to complete Trail Making Test A and Trail Making Test B was significantly (P_0.05) lower in subjects assigned to high flavanols (38.10_10.94 and 104.10_28.73 seconds, respectively) and intermediate flavanols (40.20_11.35 and 115.97_28.35 seconds, respectively) in comparison with those assigned to low flavanols (52.60_17.97 and 139.23_43.02 seconds, respectively). Similarly, verbal fluency test score was significantly (P_0.05) better in subjects assigned to high flavanols in comparison with those assigned to low flavanols (27.50_6.75 versus 22.30_8.09 words per 60 seconds). Insulin resistance, blood pressure, and lipid peroxidation also decreased among subjects in the high-flavanol and intermediate-flavanol groups. Changes of insulin resistance explained _40% of composite z score variability through the study period (partial r2_0.4013; P_0.0001). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first dietary intervention study demonstrating that the regular consumption of cocoa flavanols might be effective in improving cognitive function in elderly subjects with mild cognitive impairment. This effect appears mediated in part by an improvement in insulin sensitivity.







There are more cocoa studies:-




Cocoa Flavanols as a therapy for Autism

Based on the work of Helmut Sies and the trials funded by Mars, it is pretty obvious that 1,000mg of cocoa flavanols a day would very likely have a marked effect on someone with autism, assuming that is they were not already taking NAC, ALA, Carnosine, Broccoli, Sulforaphane or Selenium.  500 mg should also have an effect.


Choice of antioxidant

The question is what is the ultimate treatment for oxidative stress in autism?

I guess this will depend on exactly what type of autism you have (regressive or not), to what extent you have a mitochondrial dysfunction and whether you have any genetic dysfunction related to oxidative stress.

What works best in Billy, may be suboptimal in Charlie, but still much better than nothing at all.

It looks to me that NAC and ALA will likely be the most potent antioxidants.

If you live in the US, you can buy cocoa flavanols in standardized doses from Mars.  One capsule = 125mg of cocoa flavanols.   I have to add that I am far more inclined to believe Mars, than those supplement companies out there.  You can buy tablets saying they contain 50 mcg of Selenium, but what do they really contain? 

You can also buy “high flavanol” raw (non-alkalized) cocoa powder in big bags.  This lighter brown cocoa has lost far less of the flavonoids in the processing process.  In theory, a 5g teaspoon of the very best one will contain (on a good day) 415 mg of flavavols.

Mars are only supplying their CocoaVia products in North America, so if you want to try cocoa flavanols you have a few options:-

·        8.5 teaspoons of standard raw cocoa  (content will vary widely)
                or
·        1.2 teaspoons of “Chococru” upmarket raw cocoa

                or
·        4 capsules of CocoaVia from Mars  

Each of the above should give you 500mg of cocoa flavanols, which would look like a good starting point.  As with NAC, the studies show that the benefit increases the more you take, but the extra benefit drops off.

If somebody in the US tries CocoaVia, do let us know the result.

Not surprising, Mars tell us on the label that the product is not intended for children.  I do not suppose they ever thought of it being an autism therapy either.

I do like the idea of the redox switch, Nrf2, which Sulforaphane is known to activate.  I also like the idea of the enzyme GP1 that acts as catalyst in the oxidation/reduction process.

The science is around 20 years old and nobody has yet figured it all out;  they probably will not conclusively do so in the next 20 years either.


Food for thought!








Friday 25 July 2014

Carnosine for Autism – an Alternative to N-Acetylcysteine (NAC)? or is it Complementary?


Several people have mentioned to me a supplement called L-Carnosine, so I thought it was worthy of its own post.

The first thing to note is lots of supplements have very similar names and indeed two entirely different substances are abbreviated to NAC.

·        Carnosine
·        Carnitine
·        L-Carnosine
·        L-Carnitine
·        N-Acetylcysteine    (abbreviated to “NAC”)
·        N-Acetylcarnosine  (also abbreviated to “NAC”)

In this blog, and in most literature on autism, NAC refers to N-Acetylcysteine.

This post is about Carnosine and L-Carnosine, but there is also research on the use of Carnitine and L-Carnitine regarding autism and Retts syndrome.  So double check what is on the label, if you do indeed order some.


Vladimir Gulevich, Carnosine (and Carnitine)






Vladimir Gulevich  received the degree of doctor of medicine in 1896 from the department of medicine of Moscow State University. From 1900, he rejoined the Moscow State University where he was rector for a brief period of time in 1919. He was a full member of the USSR Academy of Sciences since 1929.

Gulevich discovered both Carnosine and Carnitine in his work in Moscow.  Even today his university is a centre of research for both these substances.

Carnitine and carnosine are composed of the root word carn, meaning flesh, alluding to its prevalence in animal protein. A vegetarian (especially vegan) diet is deficient in adequate carnosine, compared to levels found in a standard diet.

Researchers in Britain, South Korea, Russia and other countries have shown that carnosine has a number of antioxidant properties that may be beneficial.

Carnosine has been proven to scavenge reactive oxygen species (ROS) as well as alpha-beta unsaturated aldehydes formed from peroxidation of cell membrane fatty acids during oxidative stress.

Carnosine can chelate divalent metal ions.  DAN Doctors probably do not know what divalent means, but in Hg2+ the “2” means divalent and Hg means mercury.

Carnosine was found to inhibit diabetic nephropathy.

Carnosine-containing products are also used in topical preparations to reduce wrinkles on the skin.

Some studies have detected beneficial effects of N-acetylcarnosine in preventing and treating cataracts of the eyes.


Carnosine and Autism

Small studies, including this one by Michael Chez, have shown the benefit of L-carnosine in autism.  By the way, Chez seems to be one of the handful of genuinely knowledgeable autism clinicians anywhere on the planet.


Abstract

L-Carnosine, a dipeptide, can enhance frontal lobe function or be neuroprotective. It can also correlate with gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-homocarnosine interaction, with possible anticonvulsive effects. We investigated 31 children with autistic spectrum disorders in an 8-week, double-blinded study to determine if 800 mg L-carnosine daily would result in observable changes versus placebo. Outcome measures were the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary tests, and Clinical Global Impressions of Change. Children on placebo did not show statistically significant changes. After 8 weeks on L-carnosine, children showed statistically significant improvements on the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (total score and the Behavior, Socialization, and Communication subscales) and the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary test (all P < .05). Improved trends were noted on other outcome measures. Although the mechanism of action of L-carnosine is not well understood, it may enhance neurologic function, perhaps in the enterorhinal or temporal cortex.


As Dr Chez points out, nobody is 100% certain why it is of benefit.  It could just be the anti-oxidant properties of carnosine or it could be something related to the interaction between carnosine and GABA in the brain.  GABA is an important neurotransmitter in the brain.

Other GABA related drugs show a positive effect in types of autism.  These include Baclofen, Arbaclofen, Bumetanide, Clonazepam and even Valproic acid (VPA).  The underlying mechanisms do differ, but all relate, in one way or the other, to GABA.

The Carnosine dosage used by Dr Chez was 800mg per day.

The body deploys a range of enzymes, called carnosinases, to break down carnosine.  In order to maximize the effect, and out-smart the  carnosinases, it might be wise to split the dose into two per day.

In a perfect world it might be simpler to inhibit the carnosinases and just rely on the carnosine from meat in the diet.

You cannot patent naturally occurring substances, so nobody can patent carnosine and no drug firm will therefore research it.  A carnosinase inhibitor could be patented and therefore could be made into a drug.


Carnosine and GABA

It looks like Moscow State University is still the centre of knowledge for Carnosine and Alexander A. Boldyrev recently published a book called:-


Book Description:

The main aim of this new book is to summarize the knowledge on the metabolic transformation of carnosine in excitable tissues of animals and human beings and to analyze the nature of its biological activity. At the beginning of monograph, the short history of the problem is stated. Distribution of carnosine in tissues, its appearance in ontogeny of vertebrates and correlation between carnosine content and functional activity of tissues are discussed. Chemical properties of carnosine and its natural derivatives and their ability to bind heavy metals and protons in water solution are documented. Special attention is paid to free radical quenching ability and to anti-glycating action. Biological activity of carnosine and carnosine containing compounds was tested using biological models of several levels of complexity, starting from individual enzymes and acellular mixtures and finishing to living cells and survival animals. Effects of carnosine on the whole animals under ischemic, hypoxic and other extreme conditions are described. In conclusion, the ability of carnosine to protect brain and muscular tissues from oxidative injury during exhausting exercise, extreme loading or neurodegenerative diseases is demonstrated. Based on these properties, carnosine is postulated to be a potent protector of human beings from oxidative stress.

You can preview much of the book on Google Books

We know from many autism researchers that oxidative stress is a feature of many people’s autism.  Anything that reduces this stress should have a positive effect on behaviour.

Common antioxidants used in autism include:-

·        N-Acetlycysteine (NAC)
·        Alpha Lipoic Acid (ALA)
·        All the many “chelating” substances used by DAN Doctors

Carnosine may be just an alternative anti-oxidant.

However, when you look through Boldyrev’s book, it does look possible that the chemical relationship between GABA and Carnosine many also play a role.


Conclusion

People currently taking Carnosine for Autism might well want to try N-Acetlycysteine (NAC) and see if they notice an additional benefit.  Conversely, the current NAC converts, like my son Monty, aged 11 with ASD, may well want to give Carnosine a try and see what happens.

One blog reader with Asperger’s finds Baclofen highly beneficial; he might as well give Carnosine a try, based on the GABA relationship.

Current research indicates 2,400 mg of NAC and 800 mg of Carnosine. 

It would be nice if one day somebody would do a controlled trial of NAC vs Carnosine vs Carnosine+NAC;  but don’t hold your breath.

Some people with diabetes are already taking ALA (Alpha lipoic acid) or Thioctacid for neuropathy, but find it also increases insulin sensitivity; this means they need less insulin.  They might well find both NAC and Carnosine will further increase insulin sensitivity.  Generally speaking it seems that low insulin sensitivity is bad and high insulin sensitivity is good; but I am no expert on diabetes.

In some counties Carnosine is not available, but you simply can buy it online on Amazon, ebay or many other sites.